Told to make a Pilgrim doll for the Thanksgiving display at school, Molly is embarassed when her mother tries to help her out by creating a doll dressed as she herself was dressed before leaving Russia to seek religious freedom.

Benny anticipates making friends with the new kid down the street, but when he finds out that she's a girl, he is very disappointed.

After seeing a magician perform, Benny enlists his dog Watch to help him put on his own magic show, but then both Watch and Benny's magic bag disappear.

Benny tries to figure out why his dog, Watch, keeps escaping from the yard.