Lydia Wyse is drawn back to her childhood Amish community through her mother's "promise box," and seeks to leave behind her secular life as a book editor when she meets bachelor Gideon Hooley.
Shirley, Goodness, and Mercy--three willing but sometimes wayward angels--are each given someone's Christmas prayer to answer. But there's just one catch: each angel must teach her charge a memorable lesson before the prayer can be granted.
Touching down in New York City to perform some special holiday magic, the haphazard angel team of Shirley, Goodness, and Mercy finds three special people who share Christmas dreams.