It's Easter time in Moss Hollow, Georgia, and business at The Chocolate Shoppe Bakery is hopping--largely thanks to Jillian Green, who finally feels like she's top bunny at the bakeshop. When Jillian learns a reclusive author is considering setting his next series in Moss Hollow, she tries to impress him with a cake featuring a German chocolate called Bavarian Gold. Soon, rumors are the bakery is receiving a shipment of long-lost Nazi plunder, and things quickly spiral out of control. When Jillian's shipment of chocolate goes missing, she and her beau, Hunter Greyson hunt down the delivery truck, but when they do, they make a horrifying discovery. The FBI gets called in, and suddenly all of Moss Hollow is under investigation for a dreadful crime.