Daisy's worried one of her employees at Daisy's Tea Garden may be in a spot of trouble. Lately Karina's been loading up on soup and second-day baked goods at the end of her shift. Daisy suspects there's more going on, especially since Karina has been seen hanging out in a rundown part of Willow Creek. It turns out Karina has been helping a down on his luck single dad who's been making ends meet, by selling antiques at a place called the Pirated Treasures. But when an employee at the antiques store is bludgeoned to death with a marble rolling pin, Karina's new friend is suspect number one. Though the motives are muddy and steeped in intrigue, Daisy is more than determined to flush the real killer out.